Billy Budd, Foretopman
[Disclaimer: Have been all kinds of crazy-sick the past few days so haven't had a chance to write this up until now. Had the flu, turned into the worst sinus-cold-potentially-sinus-infection ever and yes. Not fun. Still doped up on cold medication to help relieve the pain in my head and am hoping to not have to go to walk-in clinic over the weekend if it turns out that I really do have a sinus infection. So forgive me if this does not make as much sense as I hope it will.]
My parents are currently working on de-junking their house at the moment, and in the process asked me to look through numerous boxes of books to see if there was anything I thought we should get rid of or anything I wanted to read. Most of their books I had read through high school (Wuthering Heights, The Scarlet Letter, etc.; no wonder I ended up thinking I didn’t like classics) but as I had no interest in books with sailors on the front covers back in my high school days, Billy Budd escaped my notice.
Billy Budd was left unfinished in 1891 due to Melville’s death and published in numerous different variations since his death, starting in 1924. According to Wikipedia, I read the wrong copy of this book. The version I read is an earlier version of text considered to be more along the lines of what Melville wanted - the title is aparantely supposed to be Billy Budd, Sailor: (An Inside Narrative), the ship they sail on is supposed to be a different name, there isn’t supposed to be a preface, etc. etc. etc. That said, this is the version I read, thus this is the version I am going to talk about.
Billy Budd, formerly of a merchant ship, is recruited to sail on a British warship during the Napoleonic wars. Other than a speech impediment that only appeared when excited or under duress, Budd is practically the perfect person - he’s good looking, amiable, and everyone loves him from the moment they meet him. Everyone, aside from Claggart, the Master-at-Arms. While the completely innocent and naive Budd does not realize this, Claggart soon seems to have quite the grudge growing against Budd until it gets to the point where Claggart falsely accuses Budd of mutiny.
The book was a little bit difficult to get into at first. I didn’t particularly care for the way the book was narrated, and it’s really hard to like a character that is practically perfect. Of course, the speech impediment ended up being his Achilles’ heel, which made him a bit more relatable - I don’t communicate well verbally with other people, so I can understand his desire to physically act out due to frustration - not that his acting out was forgivable by any means, but it makes it more understandable.
This book really made me ponder things. It wasn’t an easy read, but it was thought-provoking, and deals a lot with the issue of good-vs-evil, and goes into how someone should be punished if what they did was not what they meant to do. Doing the best thing for the fleet, versus doing the best thing for one man; doing your duty to prevent future trouble versus doing what is right. I don’t know what I would have chosen to do in the situation that Budd’s captain was put in.
This was my second book for the What’s in a Name challenge, and is my selection for the “book with a first name in its title” category.
Ah yes, this is indeed another astounding adventure of the wonderful and magnificent Horatio Lyle.
I went to see The Spiderwick Chronicles last night after a long day of shopping with a friend. I read a couple of reviews on various blogs where the blogger did not like the movie at all, so I wasn’t sure what to expect. While I really wanted to see this movie, I normally do not enjoy book adaptations very much. I was pleasantly surprised.
The authors I love fall into two categories. The first consists of those I love but whose books always have me feeling a little bit worried that they won’t live up to my expectations. Most authors fall into that category. The second category (with only a few people in it) consists of those authors whose books I know I will love before I even know what the book is about. Will Ferguson is one of those authors. If you’ve never heard me rave about him before, let me just say this: the man is brilliant. No word of a lie. So when I say that I can’t say enough good stuff about this book, oh boy do I mean it.